Erie County, NY vs St. Joseph County, IN
Erie County, NY and St. Joseph County, IN are even: each comes out ahead on 16 of 32 statistics where one end is better. Erie County, NY leads on Health and Economics.
32 statistics with a better end, compared
Each counts once for the place that ranks better. Totals that mostly track population are left out.
- Wins
- 16
- Avg. percentile
- 55
- Categories led
- 2
- Wins
- 16
- Avg. percentile
- 49
- Categories led
- 0
At a glance
Headline statistics, each ranked among all US counties.
| Statistic | Erie County, NY | St. Joseph County, IN |
|---|---|---|
| Population | 945,699 59th of 3,094 | 272,786 276th of 3,094 |
| Median Household IncomeHousing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | $72,839 981st of 3,093 | $66,868 1,434th of 3,093 |
| Poverty Rate (%)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 13.9% 1,694th of 3,094 | 14.2% 1,774th of 3,094 |
| Unemployment Rate (%)Unemployment Rate by County (BLS) | 4% tied 1,507th of 3,094 | 4.1% tied 1,616th of 3,094 |
| Adults Sleeping Under 7 Hours (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 38.7% tied 1,886th of 3,094 | 38.3% tied 1,748th of 3,094 |
| Average Commute (Minutes)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 21.3 912th of 3,094 | 21.1 884th of 3,094 |
| Heating Degree Days per YearClimate by County (1991–2020 Averages) | 6,724 2,343rd of 3,050 | 6,307 tied 2,207th of 3,050 |
| Median Air Quality IndexAir Quality by County (EPA) | 44 tied 692nd of 960 | 43 tied 644th of 960 |
By category
Average percentile on each category's widely ranked statistics.
- HealthErie County, NY · 11 statistics
- EconomicsErie County, NY · 8 statistics
Biggest differences
The 21 statistics where their rankings differ most, among rankings of at least 1,547 US counties.
| Statistic | Erie County, NY | St. Joseph County, IN |
|---|---|---|
| Adults with Depression (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 21.3% tied 584th of 2,916 | 27.7% tied 2,499th of 2,916 |
| Adults with Diabetes (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 9.1% tied 466th of 2,916 | 11.7% tied 1,892nd of 2,916 |
| Adults with Frequent Mental Distress (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 17.0% tied 581st of 2,916 | 19.3% tied 1,860th of 2,916 |
| Adults in Fair or Poor Health (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 16.2% tied 450th of 2,916 | 20.7% tied 1,624th of 2,916 |
| Adults 18–64 Without Health Insurance (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 6.1% tied 42nd of 2,916 | 9.2% tied 977th of 2,916 |
| Adults Who Binge Drink (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 19.2% tied 2,128th of 2,916 | 17.1% tied 1,185th of 2,916 |
| Adults Who Smoke (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 12.8% tied 412th of 2,916 | 15.6% tied 1,245th of 2,916 |
| Adults with No Leisure-Time Exercise (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 23.7% tied 794th of 2,916 | 26.1% tied 1,359th of 2,916 |
| Adults with Obesity (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 33.0% tied 440th of 2,916 | 36.0% tied 911th of 2,916 |
| Median Household IncomeHousing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | $72,839 981st of 3,093 | $66,868 1,434th of 3,093 |
| Cooling Degree Days per YearClimate by County (1991–2020 Averages) | 454 tied 485th of 3,050 | 721 tied 919th of 3,050 |
| Median Home Value (Capped at $2M)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | $233,800 2,060th of 3,092 | $192,800 1,629th of 3,092 |
| Adults with a Yearly Checkup (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 81.1% tied 44th of 2,916 | 78.9% tied 284th of 2,916 |
| Bachelor’s Degree or Higher (% of Adults 25+)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 38.0% 339th of 3,094 | 33.5% 534th of 3,094 |
| Heating Degree Days per YearClimate by County (1991–2020 Averages) | 6,724 2,343rd of 3,050 | 6,307 tied 2,207th of 3,050 |
| Adults Sleeping Under 7 Hours (%)Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES) | 38.7% tied 1,886th of 3,094 | 38.3% tied 1,748th of 3,094 |
| Unemployment Rate (%)Unemployment Rate by County (BLS) | 4% tied 1,507th of 3,094 | 4.1% tied 1,616th of 3,094 |
| Poverty Rate (%)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 13.9% 1,694th of 3,094 | 14.2% 1,774th of 3,094 |
| Median Rent (Monthly, Capped at $3,501)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | $1,090 tied 2,345th of 3,090 | $1,062 tied 2,282nd of 3,090 |
| Homes with Broadband Internet (%)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 90.2% 788th of 3,094 | 90.3% 754th of 3,094 |
| Average Commute (Minutes)Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census) | 21.3 912th of 3,094 | 21.1 884th of 3,094 |
Quick answers
- Which is better, Erie County, NY or St. Joseph County, IN?
- Erie County, NY and St. Joseph County, IN are even: each comes out ahead on 16 of 32 statistics where one end is better. Erie County, NY leads on Health and Economics. Statistics where neither end is better, and totals that mostly track population, are not counted.
- Which has more people, Erie County, NY or St. Joseph County, IN?
- Erie County, NY has a population of 945,699 (59th of 3,094 US counties) and St. Joseph County, IN has 272,786 (276th of 3,094).
- How do Erie County, NY and St. Joseph County, IN compare on Median Household Income?
- Median Household Income: Erie County, NY $72,839 (981st of 3,093), St. Joseph County, IN $66,868 (1,434th of 3,093) among US counties. Erie County, NY ranks better.
- How do Erie County, NY and St. Joseph County, IN compare on Poverty Rate (%)?
- Poverty Rate (%): Erie County, NY 13.9% (1,694th of 3,094), St. Joseph County, IN 14.2% (1,774th of 3,094) among US counties. Erie County, NY ranks better.
- Where does Erie County, NY beat St. Joseph County, IN most clearly?
- Erie County, NY ranks far ahead on Adults with Depression (%) (Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES)): 21.3% vs 27.7%; Adults with Diabetes (%) (Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES)): 9.1% vs 11.7%; Adults with Frequent Mental Distress (%) (Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES)): 17.0% vs 19.3%.
- Where does St. Joseph County, IN beat Erie County, NY most clearly?
- St. Joseph County, IN ranks far ahead on Adults Who Binge Drink (%) (Health of Adults by County (CDC PLACES)): 17.1% vs 19.2%; Median Home Value (Capped at $2M) (Housing, Income and Commutes by County (Census)): $192,800 vs $233,800; Heating Degree Days per Year (Climate by County (1991–2020 Averages)): 6,307 vs 6,724.
More matchups
Other comparisons with Erie County, NY or St. Joseph County, IN.